Daily Relo Ticker-May 14, 2026: Renting vs Buying
- Martin Mayotte
- May 14
- 3 min read
Daily Relo Ticker
Welcome to today’s Daily Relo Ticker (DRT)- your quick, straightforward update on the relocation world as of May 2026. A trusted source, pairing 15+ years of industry experience and over a dozen of personal moves. Listed below are topics, trends and current job postings in the industry. Please consider sharing for maximum reach and while there are no royalties, kickbacks or fees, any move related referral would be greatly appreciated!
Featured News: Renting vs Buying
SFR Share of Rentals at Record Low
Multi-family (especially large buildings) gaining share as single-family construction lags. 31% of U.S. rentals are single-family homes (record low); 33% in large multi-family. Redfin https://finance.yahoo.com/news/single-family-rental-decline-133000506.html
Regional Variations (Sun Belt Oversupply)
High-supply Sun Belt markets see softer conditions vs. tighter Northeast/Midwest. Declines in Austin, Phoenix, etc.; stronger in NYC, Chicago, SF. Industry Reports / Yardi
Renewals Prioritized Over New Leases
Operators focus on keeping existing tenants amid soft demand. Strong renewal bumps (~3%+ possible); new lease growth lower. CBRE / Multifamily Dive
Shift Toward Professional/ Institutional Management
More rentals under professional operators, including BTR communities. Institutional and REIT activity stable/selective; mom-and-pop still dominant but shifting. SitusAMC / Reports
Broader U.S. picture favors buying in more places:
ATTOM's 2026 data showed it was cheaper to buy (monthly costs as % of local wages) than rent a 3-bedroom in 57.7% of U.S. counties analyzed (210 out of 364). This was especially true in the Midwest and South, where lower prices and better affordability ratios help.
Renting beats buying in major metros:
According to Realtor.com's March 2026 Rental Report, buying a starter home cost an average of $920 more per month (55% higher) than renting across the 50 largest metros. This held true in all 50 areas, with the biggest gaps in places like San Jose ($2,425/month savings renting), Los Angeles, and Boston. Rents for 0-2 bedroom units fell 1.5% year-over-year, marking the 32nd straight month of declines
Overall, 2026 is a year of stabilization rather than dramatic shifts. Renting is a smart, low-risk choice for many (especially in expensive cities or for those prioritizing flexibility/savings), while buying makes sense for long-term residents in affordable areas who can handle the costs. Consult local data, a real estate pro, or rent-vs-buy calculators tailored to your situation, as trends are highly location-dependent.
Helpful Resources: Renting vs Buying
From 2016–2021, buying a home in the U.S. was generally cheaper on a monthly basis than renting when looking only at principal-and-interest mortgage payments. Low mortgage rates helped offset rising home prices, allowing many buyers to build equity while keeping monthly payments below typical asking rents.
That trend shifted dramatically beginning in 2022. Rapid home price appreciation combined with sharply higher mortgage rates caused monthly ownership costs to surge. By 2023–2025, the estimated monthly mortgage payment on a median-priced home exceeded national asking rents by several hundred dollars per month in many markets.
However, the chart only reflects mortgage principal and interest (P&I). Actual homeownership costs are significantly higher once property taxes, homeowners insurance, maintenance, HOA dues, and repairs are included.
Typical Additional Monthly Ownership Costs (National Averages)
Expense | Estimated Monthly Add-On |
Property Taxes | $300–$500 |
Homeowners Insurance | $125–$250 |
Maintenance/Repairs Reserve | $300–$700 |
HOA Fees (where applicable) | $0–$400+ |
Total Additional Cost | ~$725–$1,850/month |
Using the 2026 estimate from the graph:
Base mortgage payment (P&I only): about $1,980/month
Estimated all-in ownership cost: roughly $2,700–$3,800/month
That means taxes, insurance, and maintenance can add approximately:
+$700 to +$1,800 per month
or roughly 35%–90% above the mortgage payment itself
This helps explain why many households today perceive buying as substantially more expensive than renting, even when mortgage rates begin to stabilize. While homeowners still benefit from equity growth, tax advantages, and long-term payment stability, the upfront monthly affordability gap has widened considerably since 2022.
Key Takeaways:
Renting costs rose steadily over the decade, but buying costs accelerated much faster after 2021.
Mortgage rates became the largest driver of affordability deterioration.
“True” homeownership costs extend far beyond the mortgage payment.
In high-tax or high-insurance states, the all-in monthly cost of ownership can exceed rent by well over $1,000/month.
Maintenance is often underestimated; a common planning rule is 1%–2% of home value annually for upkeep and repairs.
Comments